If you go to the Facebook you can see pictures of the shop from the 1900′s and it looks identical to how the store looks now.
I ordered vanilla ice cream with marshmallow, caramel, and hot fudge sauce because I like decadence. Quality handmade stuff. Although after I ordered I noticed they have a seasonal peach ice cream in stock. I should have gone that way.
Aglamesis Brothers also sells homemade chocolates and ice cream by the pint. And the store is open until 10:30 every night. What other ice cream place does that?